ALIENS: A masterpiece in so many aspects, a timeless clasic, it redefined sci fi and terror movies forever, etc. All the shit that we all know.
Ridley its still a director with a touch, even he has some horrible and boring movies. I hope he can demonstrate that he is really back in Prometheus, but I really doubt it....
ALIENS: The same as before, but this time for SCI FI and action movies.
For me, it´s trully hard to decide wich one is better. I enjoy more watching Aliens, but I think Alien is better by a 0,1%.
Even this is his best movie ever, cameron did more amazing films, till he crashed with a block of ice and did two of the most irritating and anoying movies ever.
Alien 3: I dont hate it and I actually like it a lot, its not even close to Alien or Aliens, but it if wasn´t for all the production problems, It coul´d been amazing.
ALIEN RESURECTION: I hate a 90% of it, but I think that Jean Piere had good intentions, even he missed the tone completely. Anyway, horrible.
PREDATOR: A clasic and a cult movie but far away from beeing a masterpiece like Alien or Aliens. I mean, galaxies away from each other. I love it but its not the same as alien/s. (Im not going to make a lot of friends here...).
You gotta love Mctiernan. he is a true craftsman. But not a genius. Just a really competent filmmaker. He did good things and bad things after, but I just love the guy.
PREDATOR 2: A funny movie that I dont hate anything on it, but i dont love anything on it (besides Glover), and because the first one is what it is, this one is enough good for a secuel.
Stephen hopkins direction was so plain that he was even incapable of ruining it. I have doubts that he was even there during filming....if a squirrell with a camera had directed it, the movie would be exactly the same.
EDIT:
I forgot About PREDATORS: Fun and respectuous with the franchise, but quite boring. And the Predator Hound is the exact shit that happens because CGI. Somebody cames up with a horrible idea and it ends in the movie because you CAN actually do it with CGI. Before, a lot of stupid ideas didnt reach the screen because, thanks god, they where imposible to do.
Nimrod Antal direction has no personality at all, and the characters are just ok. I dont hate the movie at all, but I don´t think I am going to watch it never again. (the only movie im really interested of the PRedators franchise is the first one.).
AVP 1 and AVP:R : For starters I am not very fond on the AVP premise, but as a fan of SCI FI, give me a decent movie and i will devorate it. But if its possible, dont mess with Alien please. Do a Predator VS Riddick, Predators VS JAR JAR, a Predator VS ET, whatever, but dont f**k around with Alien. And if you do, please have a minimum respect for it. But in this two movies, they didnt had any respect for Alien, and not even for Predator, degradating both characters at shamefull levels.
Both movies are an insult to intelligence, an insult to movies, an insult to directors. nothing is worth on them. Life would be much better if they disapear forever.
In my world, they don´t exists.
Anderson is a plain director that make mvies that I can enjoy on a sunday afternoon with a masive hangover and my brain just in mode off, (Event Horizon its the best thing he ever did), so, not a guy that you want behing anything related to Alien...
The Strause brothers should quit directing forever. All their movies are just crap. I trully hink they are good people and that have the best of the intentions, but they have no talent for directing, and somebody should tell em. ( seems that hollywood allready told em).