Quote from: Lemonade on Jun 25, 2014, 12:23:49 AM
Ok. Where did I say that the new predator film should be anything like a marvel movie? Do you always put words in people's mouths? That's like you saying I said predator 2 has the format of elm street 5.
When you wrote this:
Quote from: Lemonade on Jun 24, 2014, 09:29:20 PM
Honestly, y'all should be happy. The dude who directed a big, billion dollar grossing Marvel movie, is taking the reigns of the Predator franchise.
You were essentially saying that someone who's been heavily involved in a Marvel film is automatically a great choice for a '
Predator' film. I was pointing out that the Marvel experience is largely irrelevant, tone-wise.
You can find someone who's raised cattle all their life, but it doesn't mean they'll necessarily be great with a crocodile farm.
For all any of us know, there's an equal chance of it being good, bad or average. Hyping it as guaranteed success is just as bad as damning it as automatic failure.
Quote from: HuDaFuK on Jun 25, 2014, 03:59:31 PM
I don't think you comprehend quite how mind-bogglingly stupid the idea of carrying around and firing a minigun is. Next to that, having a few shooters in your trunk is pretty much common sense.
But the viewer tends to buy it. That's what matters. If we took out everything which, from a purely
technical point of view, is at least highly unlikely, how many action films out there would survive the cull? We watch them for escapist entertainment value, not because we secretly want to sit through '
Mythbusters'.
The catch is whether the stunt/spectacle/event is conveyed
effectively or not. Would Sandra Bullock have been able to leap between those space stations in real life? Hell, no. But you're not going to tell me that technical fact makes '
Gravity' any less compelling/powerful.
QuotePredator 2 is mad, sure. But it's by no means more mad than the first one.
It's
infinitely more insane... Where's the equivalent of, say, the old lady who single-handedly manages to destroy the tense atmosphere of the Predator's medical recovery scene with a comical, "I don't think he gives a shit"?
Stuff like that was just plain cringe-worthy.