A:CM was indeed a bad game but I did enjoy some parts of it even if it was for mindless fun
but there really was no tension in the game, well arguably there was in sewer scene and getting chased by the Raven, but that wore off pretty quickly because of how easy is it to beat it in ultimate badass mode.
AVP2010 was not the best either, at worst its mediocre and gets boring quickly, at best its average with good animations and quite fun, but the (really) short campaigns, lack of engagment and emersion of being an Alien or Predator coupled with bad multiplayer setup (if this was done right, the game would be really popular) ruins the game, however, the marine campaign is arguably the best and in the first few levels, it does capture some of the tension of previous avp games, the second game by monolith arguably still tops it though.