Right now I'm the same because I have only seen AvP-R once, and I am looking forward to the "extended" edition. Also curious to watch it in HD! However, if someone asked me which they should watch if they could only pick one, I'd w/out a doubt suggest AvP. Not sure why they'd only be allowed to watch just one...maybe their communist overlords only allow one aliens related movie... lol. mmmkay..