Paul W.S Anderson or The Strause Brothers for AVP3?

[echobbase79]

What kills that moment is the stupid long tail they used to achieve that. Music was good though.

[Requiem28]

What kills that moment is the stupid long tail they used to achieve that.

that's true. 

[echobbase79]

The Bros. if I had to choose.

[OmegaZilla]

After having stabbed repeatedly myself with one more vision of AvPR I wholeheartedly confirm my preference for Anderson.
Anderson can make some sort of decent character development that manages you to remember at least one or two memorable characters. The Brothers can't. Not one character that was kind of rememberable. ONE.
Anderson can use a dark photography without managing it to be so dark that you almost have to use night goggles to see it. The Brothers do the other way around.

And last but not least,
Anderson can do fu**ing pacing.

[Noir-Gojira]

What kills that moment is the stupid long tail they used to achieve that.

that's true.

I didn't even notice it until the fans started to bitch and moan.

[OmegaZilla]

I find myself in a situation much like Noir's. Never, never noticed it.
To be sincere I have a hard time noticing it's "stretched" even now.

[Master]

Me too.

---Edit---


And to be honest, I`d take gigant tails any day insted of such f**ked up Predalien!

[OmegaZilla]

Or the almighty Octopus Man.
Or Hyperthiroidic Aliens.
Or a Space Jockey in a Trophy Room.
Gaaah!

[Master]

  [throws up on keyboard and monitor]

Why you had to remind me this? Why!

[OmegaZilla]

I watched AvPR yesterday.
I have to get something out of my system or I will explode out of the hate!

[Master]

Lest time I`ve seen AvP-r was in 2007. And I`m not going to touch this film anywhere soon.

[OmegaZilla]

*Sighs* It was 2 years. I was so optimist...

[Master]

You know what, my girlfriend is also A/P enthusiast. She watched all Alien, Predator and first AvP film and wanted to try AvP-r. I told her that this is a really shitty way to lose another two hours of her life.

But get back to the subject. I strongly believe that with good script Anderson can make really good AvP film.

[OmegaZilla]

Yeah, the weak point of Anderson is script. Because his visuals are fantastic. Another good thing is that he, along with the SFX maker, wanted to keep what rendered the A/Ps great in their films, alas the suits. The only cgi shots are the "necessary" ones.

[dallevalle]

ok honestly if there should ever be a avp 3 movie and it should be between those directors then yeah im going with anderson and my only reason for that is he is a better director.