All Star Wars

[BigChapismyBestFriend]

What do you think about this hate for Disney Star Wars?

I feel like it's is Justifiable in a sort of sense, but there are some people who do go way too far and dismissing anything that is from Disney rather Andor, Mandalorian, and the Jedi fallen order series.

The vitriol isn't remotely justifiable. People will like some and not others. There's plenty of legit criticisms to make. But it's not Disney. People shat on Jedi for the Ewoks, then they shat on the Ewok movies, then they shat on TPM, AOTC and to a lesser extent ROTS. Then The Clone Wars. All before Disney was anywhere near it.

They're just angry that they're not eight years old anymore.

Yeah, but they legit do have Reasons to be angry with the crappy writing, From Disney. It's just the things that I'm questioning is how hostile these fans can be.

[SM]

There's plenty of legit criticisms to make.

A certain proportion have always been hostile simply because George didn't endlessly remake The Empire Strikes Back.

[Local Trouble]

I'm a certain proportion.

[SM]

We are aware.

[BigChapismyBestFriend]

There's plenty of legit criticisms to make.

A certain proportion have always been hostile simply because George didn't endlessly remake The Empire Strikes Back.

That's pretty silly.

[Local Trouble]

 

[BigChapismyBestFriend]

Not your Proposal but, The fact that they did that

[SM]

There's plenty of legit criticisms to make.

A certain proportion have always been hostile simply because George didn't endlessly remake The Empire Strikes Back.

That's pretty silly.

Obviously. Many simply can't help it though.

[Local Trouble]

I'm like the proverbial scorpion on the frog's back.

[BigChapismyBestFriend]

There's plenty of legit criticisms to make.

A certain proportion have always been hostile simply because George didn't endlessly remake The Empire Strikes Back.

That's pretty silly.

Obviously. Many simply can't help it though.

Really wish that this stop. Some of them are using Disney and "wokeness" as Excuse to act horrible

[kwisatz]

I'm actually pretty capable to overlook even many flaws of certain entries when I feel that the overall film is good or at least OKish.

Like this is true for Return, Rogue One, TFA hell even for Episode 1 where I love some of the stuff so much I can even (partially) endure that Gungan shitshow. Return and Episode 1 are actually pretty similar experiences for me in that regard.

But films like Episode 2 and 3, TLJ and Rise etc are such awful crapfests I'm totally unable to see anything beautiful (there probably is) beyond their massive failure to work for me as something that remotely resembles a watchable film.

Is all taste tho 

[Immortan Jonesy]

TLJ is visually beautiful

[kwisatz]

Prometheus and Rez too :/

[SM]

There's plenty of legit criticisms to make.

A certain proportion have always been hostile simply because George didn't endlessly remake The Empire Strikes Back.

That's pretty silly.

Obviously. Many simply can't help it though.

Really wish that this stop. Some of them are using Disney and "wokeness" as Excuse to act horrible

If it wasn't Disney they'd find another excuse.

[BigChapismyBestFriend]

There's plenty of legit criticisms to make.

A certain proportion have always been hostile simply because George didn't endlessly remake The Empire Strikes Back.

That's pretty silly.

Obviously. Many simply can't help it though.

Really wish that this stop. Some of them are using Disney and "wokeness" as Excuse to act horrible

If it wasn't Disney they'd find another excuse.

Maybe you're correct. I just wish people weren't so hostile