Someone requested this review, so..
![](https://www.avpgalaxy.net/forum/proxy.php?request=http%3A%2F%2Fupload.wikimedia.org%2Fwikipedia%2Fen%2F1%2F1c%2FWatchmenPosterFinal.jpg&hash=1eecf61ee4ac19d63111a6631f7e8ce53bf18a7a)
THEATRICAL CUT
Plot/Script -
This is based on the highly rated graphic novel by Alan Moore. On many "best of" lists, I haven't read it, but from the reviews it seems to have stuck pretty closely to the comic. The major change was the ending - no squid.
Anyway - this has a highly complex plot and alot of characters but it just doesn't skillfully weave it all together to make a 100% coherent film. But I'm not rating on it until I see the extended edition, as granted there are alot of issues condensing this graphic novel down to a 2 hour and 40 minute film without completely changing it.
Time will tell.
Visuals 94%
The CGI is great but the cinematography I did not find that awe-inspiring especially after the great work on The Dark Knight.
Of course the film is full of memorable images like the pyramid in Antarctica, the naked blue "god-man", Rorschach with his constantly shifting ink-blot mask - classic images from the comic that are well brought to life.
Sound 70%
Score - the soundtrack wasn't that great, I mean they could've chosen some better period music but maybe it was a rights issue.
Acting 81%
Huge cast of unknowns here so I'll go by character:
Rorschach - this guy really made the movie for me, he really nailed this character who was kind of like a mix between Dirty Harry and The Punisher. Great performance.
Dr. Manhattan - understated performance of a god-man was kind of surreal. Another great character.
Nite Owl II - "the normal guy" his main arch that he can't get it up unless he's playing superhero.
Silk Spectre II - uber-slutty is the word, I can't say I liked her character that much and didn't really care for her story.
The Comedian - very small part for this guy, we don't find out much about why he turned from a rapist/killer to someone with a conscience.
Ozymandias - did not like this guy, his delivery is a bit flat and he looks like a pretty boy.
Violence
Lots of blood, people exploding, stabbings, mutiliations, attempted rape - it's all very over the top, though. Not as bad as Snyder's 300 but very comic book style.
Sex
Alot of sex, surprisingly. Frankly, I did not like the sex scenes, the one in the ship was a little ridiculous.
Overall 85%
I did like this movie, it's even in my top 10 comic book movies but not anywhere near the top of the list. It's main problems for me were an incoherent structure, some boring or stupid scenes and bad dialogue.
However, it's interesting to me that it is about moral ambiguity and drawing grey lines around such things as false flag terror attacks and covering up the truth at all costs. I'm sure the Illuminati will love this movie.
Now I compare it to other comic book movies I liked:
*It definitely wasn't straightforward in it's narrative - but it didn't handle the complex narrative well. If you like more straightforward stuff than I recommend something like Iron Man.
*It went for some realism, but The Dark Knight far succeeded in that department.
*X Men 2 managed to deal with the emotional issues in a less forced way.
*The production design didn't go for real world, terribly fantastic or gritty. Slightly noirorish, but it didn't have as much character as such films like TMNT (1990) or Batman (1989). And TMNT was set in New York but every shot of NY in Watchmen felt like it was filmed on a stage or computer generated (Ghostbusters is another great NY movie).
*Rorschach was a badass and beats out pretty much any other anti-superhero IMO besides Marv who could plainly kick his ass.
*Dr Manhattan is the ultimate naked superhero dude, better than Silver Surfer.
*The idea, though is original and I think Moore is a genius.