Hard choice for me...I actually enjoyed both these movies in the Cinema.
Yes they have their faults, and yes they could have been alot more...but in the end I did enjoy them.
I liked the story for the first movie, I thought it was pretty clever, with the Pyramid being the training grounds for the Predators etc, it was too watered down maybe, but then I'm not really looking for the measurement of blood in a movie, it was entertaining and loved the action scenes in them, even if there were few. Just to see two of my favourite sc-fi/horror icons on the screen was good enough for me.
The second movie...I enjoyed just as much, my own major gripe with this movie was, it all moved to quickly, and the lack of money to make the movie kinda showed....if they were given the right budget, this movie would have been alot better, but 20th Century Fox has still obviously not learnt anything, and I think their just ignoring the fans full stop.
But yeah, enjoyed this one, some neat designs, cool action scenes, people complained the screen was soo dark that they couldn't see much...I actually liked this, me being me.
I had to choose the 2nd movie, as I feel it tired to give more, but it couldn't...and it was not the Directors fault I dont think...
The acting was actually better than I thought it would be too, with all the mostly unknown actors in it...