No one's holding a grudge. The discussion was about Blomkamp's retcon and the possibilities. So repeating "yes, but it it didn't happen that way in Alien3" in a variety of ways is missing the point. The vast majority of people on here know what happened in Alien3 and to be honest, many of the discussions on this forum hypothetical "what ifs." You could, for instance, go onto the Shane Black Predator thread and announce the whole discussion was pointless and we won't know till the film comes out. Or will there be an Alien Queen in Isolation 2. We don't know yet. Or could there be an Amanda Ripley film - go pick 'em.
Consequently, if that's your standpoint, why bother commenting on these threads if you have no interest in "what ifs" and keep quoting the rulebook. But that's your cross to bear, I guess.