Giger's criticism of the scene isn't mine. You'd be surprised at how critical he was/is of things in Alien. He said his initial viewing of the film left him 'depressed', that the Alien suit looked terrible and was 'so bad it helped Ridley could only show it in glimpses', etc. etc. But to finish, Giger is optimistic: However, you are always the winner if you have created something that is enjoyed and, although my reputation as an artist has suffered, that's how I feel about Alien.' I would be very happy myself.