Quote from: Darkfox426 on Oct 29, 2009, 02:15:58 PM
Maybe, maybe not - we are not told how much the Company knew, Ash seemed sometimes like knowing more than he admitted (even apart from the basic things he was hiding from the crew). Anyway, the more would one be interested in what the heck is the movie going to be about I'd really wonder, then... as if you had something with Aliens there, you need to wipe out the humans in order for it to make sense that nobody knew about the Aliens until Nostromo.
Ripley only had a partial translation, which was enough to inform her of it having probable 'warning' connotations.
At best, we can probably assume that there was some sort of mention about a dangerous, extremely hostile lifeform. Possibly even with allusions of it being 'viral' and contagious. Any creature attempting to broadcast a legitimate warning wouldn't be so counter-productive as to provide genetic schematics and the like for any interested intergalactic parties.
Weyland-Yutani about a 'lifeform'. They knew it was dangerous. They wanted a sample retrieved or a useful survey done.
If they knew more than that, they would have sent a dedicated team. They must have been at least equipped for containing such things, back home or had access to subcontractors who would, after all.
QuoteIndeed! I think some things should be left buried where they belong, with a few obscure hints to sort of keep them alive, but no blunt revelations.
Right. I have no problem with that, so long as it doesn't feel forced there. The strength in the entire derelict thing is its allusion to 'star gods', in a very Lovecraftian manner. It looks like a scene which played out long before humanity even came to exist - and implies intergalactic terrors well in excess of anything we have imagined. Just look at the cavern scene... It stretches on, it goes aorund the corner. You see it and you wonder, hmm... Are there
just eggs, down there? What if they're just a small fraction of the horrors in that section?
It has a way of filling you with very disturbing awe, when you watch it for a second time, that way, because you're already aware of what going down there results in. It's clever, as it gives the film some very iconic rewatch value.
The trouble with a prequel is that the Alien as a pre-determined fate. We know that it won't be able to get to a populated world. We know that, at best, any ship it's on is going to be destroyed. For the same reason as the '
Alien Versus Predator' films, there won't be any epic high stakes at play. The best we can hope for is a particularly grotesque and memorable haunted house atmosphere.