Paul W.S Anderson or The Strause Brothers for AVP3?

[Lar'ja Thwei]

I read all the posts.

Still have no idea why he'd want the two together.

Like i said earlier. They both have different ideas and styles. Theres a reason he could want them together.

[SiL]

But one of a director's job is to have a cohesive style throughout the film. You don't get anything by slapping people with two wholly different styles in the director's chair but an inconsistent mess or a compromise that results in just one style anyway.

[Lar'ja Thwei]

It doesn't have to be one style throughout the whole thing..and it doesn't have to be a mess. You can't know for sure what the result would be, before it happens. Even if there was one style, it could be really awesome if both of their ideas were blended together in a very unique way.

[SM]

Something worse than both AvPs would certainly be unique.

[PredalienXenomorph]

Something worse than both AvPs would certainly be unique.

You give Ressurection too much credit 

[SM]

You give your attempt at humour too much credit 

[Lar'ja Thwei]

Something worse than both AvPs would certainly be unique.

I'm sure it would.

[PredalienXenomorph]

Whatever, it's true.

[SiL]

Alien Resurrection isn't worse than the AvP movies.

[PredalienXenomorph]

Your entitled to your opinion as I am to mine.

[SM]

Last time I checked, in every quantifiable sense - inflation adjusted box office, IMDB ratings, RT ratings - Resurrection is a better film.

[Deco]

Neither - both a terrible directors and really dont deserve to be given all that money to make the crap they produce... Thats like saying, lets get M NIGHT SHITMALAN to direct AVP 3

[OpenMaw]

Neither - both a terrible directors and really dont deserve to be given all that money to make the crap they produce... Thats like saying, lets get M NIGHT SHITMALAN to direct AVP 3

I agree with the stuff this poster said. 

[DoomRulz]

Last time I checked, in every quantifiable sense - inflation adjusted box office, IMDB ratings, RT ratings - Resurrection is a better film.

I can't argue with this. But, as I've said countless times before, I prefer the AvP movies to Resurrection because as bad as they are, they wanted to do something different. Resurrection just kind of came outta nowhere with a really, really random storyline and new Alien design.

[Lar'ja Thwei]

I don't mind resurrection, when i think of the story to myself it sounds amazing, but for some reason the movie wasn't THAT great. I still liked it though, better than both AvP's.