Poll: AvP vs AvPR

[DoomRulz]

Meh, it's still ahead.

[Alexa Chung]

Do 283 people really prefer AvPR? By what criteria? Least intrusive background imagery while sticking crack rocks up one's nose? Jesus Christ.

[Spaghetti]

Hohohoho

[SpaceMarines]

No, that's Santa Christ who does that.

[The Demon]

Do 283 people really prefer AvPR? By what criteria? Least intrusive background imagery while sticking crack rocks up one's nose? Jesus Christ.

The wolf and the violence is my reasoning.

[DoomRulz]

Or maybe you know, they were entertained more so than they were with AvP.

[SM]

Don't be stupid.  That can't be it!

[Deathly_rYaN]

ummmm... i really just go with AvP. i mean it has a better story than AvP-R

[huntin8-t0n]

better story? If I think about it, avp has no story at all. Nor has AVP-R I agree.

[SM]

Of course AvP has a story.  'Predators attract humans to Bouvetoya to be hosts for Aliens for their manhood ritual of hunting Aliens'.

[TJ Doc]

And it has stronger performances.

And a more unique and interesting setting.

And a decent(ish) range of (mostly) developed characters.

[SM]

Not saying much.
Agreed.
Eh?

[huntin8-t0n]

Of course AvP has a story.  'Predators attract humans to Bouvetoya to be hosts for Aliens for their manhood ritual of hunting Aliens'.

Yupp, but everything other is just a modification of an idea that's not (and for a long time possibly can't be) proved. Like puzzle. 'In this case avpr's story is 'an alien spaceship falls from the sky, then monsters start harvesting the town's population. Then a comrade of the fallen ship's passengers arrives to clean up the mess, while the survivors of the townsfolk get between the crossfire.' I mean both of these are just ridiculeous, and comparsion is pointless. It's just how I see it of course, no offense.

Stronger performance stands for one person and one person only. You know who he is.
Unique and interesting setting. Agreed (though the background of it is just... no polite words). Still it has nothing to do with the story IMO.

And a decent(ish) range of (mostly) developed characters.

I don't see why, could you explain

[SM]

Yupp, but everything other is just a modification of an idea that's not (and for a long time possibly can't be) proved.

Either way - point still stands.  Both AvP and AvP:Poo do have stories.  Their quality is a matter of opinion.

[TJ Doc]

Not saying much.

Bah.

And a decent(ish) range of (mostly) developed characters.

I don't see why, could you explain

Well alright, but they're certainly a more varied bunch compared to Requiem's flesh bags.