Quote from: OmegaZilla on Aug 03, 2012, 07:43:15 PM
Quote from: Space Sweeper on Aug 03, 2012, 07:20:48 PM
Well, aside from the first movie, and to it's best, in Aliens and Alien3
Do not get me wrong, as I love Alien3, but it arguably was the start of the 'unscary' Alien. Aside from the brilliant design, the Runner wasn't used as well, and didn't have the same presence or menace as the Aliens from the first two films.
I think we could both agree there, but that would be because it had two options: follow the similar behaviors and presentation of the previous aliens and lose most of the effect or deviate and lose the effect altogether. Each movie has moved farther and farther away from scary, and that's because the creature only has so much steam in it. The first movie was clearly meant to be a horror film, but a large part of that was with the stunningly horrific alien qualities of the creature and it's dark sexual undertones. Now it's "been there done that", and during re-watches the fear comes from that creature originality and the masterful filmmaking that went with it.
Quote from: OmegaZilla on Aug 03, 2012, 07:43:15 PM
Quote from: Space Sweeper on Aug 03, 2012, 07:20:48 PM
The creature has effectively gone from terrifying to "Oh".
That'd be because there has not been a 'terrifying' Alien film after the second one, as no one managed yet to replicate, or even come close to (which is undoubtely not impossible) the wonder of Alien and Aliens.
And the point is that it can't be replicated because that level of fear that came from the creature was a one time thing, and worked seeing the creature in a different light in Aliens. No matter how you capture the alien now, we'd have already seen it. All the jump scares and all the dark lighting in the world wouldn't do it again. It's time to move on, and that's the point. For the same creature, it's undoubtedly impossible.
Unless you're a fan of repetition, it's time to move on and contribute to the universe instead of rehash. One of the best things about Prometheus was that there was no xenomorph presence to affect the story, and therefore made it feel like something new.