Alien Covenant Fan Reviews

[lv_226]

As of now, 191 people are saying this movie was 'good' or better, and 139 are 'it was okay' or worse. I can live with that.

I think the 'Okay' category would be the outlier category here as it could be interpreted as going either way. If we throw it out, then we have 191 who say they 'like' Covenant and 73 who says they "didn't like' Covenant—not trying to confirm my own bias, but I am fascinated by survey methodology.

[BishopShouldGo]

Wait so what did SiL think of Covenant? SM?

Here's what Sil had to say.

Spoiler

Aliens are derived from combining space wasps with black goo mutations/10

[close]

Good first half. Bad second half. Aliens felt like they were fan service and really shouldn't been kept out. Dumber characters than Prometheus, or at least, one person dumber than them combined.

Not sure what SM thought.

Thank you!

[426Buddy]

As of now, 191 people are saying this movie was 'good' or better, and 139 are 'it was okay' or worse. I can live with that.

I would think "it was okay" would be a postive vote, not a negative one. But hey whatever floats your boat.

[stroggificated]

For a fanpage this is a bad poll result for the movie.

[juxtapose]

For a fanpage this is a bad poll result for the movie.

i actually think it's very positive considdering how nitpicky fans generally are. .the 2 bottom choices are the only teally negative ones. .

. .the top 3 are generally positive and thats like 77 percent. .really not bad all considered. .

[Rankles75]

Nearly 80% scored it 3/5 or higher, don't see how that's bad...

[426Buddy]

Nearly 80% scored it 3/5 or higher, don't see how that's bad...

Its actually great considering how fractured and jaded this fandom has always been.

[SM]

Wait so what did SiL think of Covenant? SM?

I only watched it last night.  Really enjoyed it.  More satisfying than Prometheus.  My only issues are the twist that could hardly be called a twist, and the ending was a bit mean spirited.

[Whos_Nick]

Where's the review from SiL

[SM]

For a fanpage this is a bad poll result for the movie.

i actually think it's very positive considdering how nitpicky fans generally are. .the 2 bottom choices are the only teally negative ones. .

. .the top 3 are generally positive and thats like 77 percent. .really not bad all considered. .

Yeah. Over 3/4 of people gave it a positive score.

[Salt The Fries]

Wait so what did SiL think of Covenant? SM?

I only watched it last night.  Really enjoyed it.  More satisfying than Prometheus.  My only issues are the twist that could hardly be called a twist, and the ending was a bit mean spirited.

What took you so long? I'm glad you caught it in its theatrical run, though.

[SM]

Busy.

[HuDaFuK]

For a fanpage this is a bad poll result for the movie.

To be honest, if I wasn't a fan I think I would've enjoyed it more, given that most of the things in it that annoyed me were to do with screwing around with continuity.

[Alien³]

most of the things in it that annoyed me were to do with screwing around with continuity.

What continuity was messed with?

[HuDaFuK]

The Chestburster suddenly looking a midget instead of a snake for one. Utterly pointless change.

There's also the magical instantaneous implantation.