Sticking to the original formula is a bad thing? Uh it's Aliens vs Predators... should they be having a dance off instead? Granted I'm biased, but this guy isn't even making claims that make sense nor is he backing up his claims. The gameplay trailers they play during that small bit basically refute the claims he makes.
Had he said, the game was disappointing due to X,Y,Z then it might be credible, but to just say that they're sticking to the same formula and spin it as a bad thing... that's just bullsh*t.