I mean, to each his own but historically, most xenomorph toys or movie incarnations have been negatively compared to Big Chap or Cameron's Warrior.
Personally, the more distance that can be put from those, the better. If they just recycled the same old design it would make a cool homage for about 2 seconds before it would be thought of as lazy and unoriginal.
The beauty of the Alien, and what separates it from everything from Jaws to Jason Voorhees is that it evolves so you never know exactly what form it will take next.
I just wish some fans kept more of an open mind and evolved with it. But again, respect to the traditionalists out there. Everybody's got a preference.