Quote from: Ingwar on Mar 17, 2017, 10:35:24 PM
Are you for real? He wasn't just a cog. He was essential part of the machine next to O'Bannonr/Shusett, Giller/Hill and Giger. He actually convinced studio to use Giger's work . Studio didn't like it but Scott insisted. He and O'Bannon perceived its potential.
If there were equally essential people then yes, he was a cog in a machine. A machine of very talented, creative cogs. For example, Scott might've convinced them to go with Giger, but it was
O'Bannon who convinced
Scott to begin with. The creativity of the Alien itself was from O'Bannon, Shussett, Cobb and Giger. Scott's major contributions were "tall thin person in the suit", "graceful movements" and "take off the eyes". Great touches, but icing on a cake built by a lot of other chefs.
Scott was less the creator of
Alien than, say, Cameron was the creator of
The Terminator. Scott was one of a group of people coming together at the right time to make a great film, but he was never the creative driving force behind the whole thing.