Quote from: Russ on Jan 03, 2015, 08:46:30 AM
I think he's pretty much said it's P3 - not a reboot, sidequel or retcon.
I know that Antal said he considered it the third film, but Rodriguez equated it to being his version of the second. There are interviews of Rodriguez saying that if he did a sequel, he'd name the PREDATORS sequel as Predator 3. But that's neither here nor there now.
Quote from: Russ on Jan 03, 2015, 08:46:30 AM
Tossing out the old EU, New novels, new comics, new game, new word on "Paradise", that big book that SM worked on, this movie with Shane. That's a lot of movement on a "dead" franchise.
That's... why I have a problem with the new stuff. Just the approach that it was done with. Like how you said, tossing out the EU stuff and everything. Star Wars gets everything in the last thirty or so years under a "Legends" banner. What pisses me off a bit is that for us fans who liked the old EU don't even get that. But then again... this is the second time the old EU was rebooted. Remember the Hish mythos? That supposedly rebooted the Yautja stuff.
Quote from: Russ on Jan 03, 2015, 08:46:30 AM
I digress - I very much doubt if Predator 3 will be risk-taking film - like, we often read on here "I want a film in Yatjua language from the Predators point of view" - that won't happen. I will take a forfeit on that too - If it does, I'll go get a a back, sack and crack wax.
Shane's movie is going to be an "inventive" sequel. Whatever "inventive" ideas are in mind.. I just hope it's something that isn't too radical like PREDATORS was. I mean I get that PREDATORS wanted to expand things a little bit but I felt that Rodriguez and company completely missed what Predator was all about. What I mean by that was the whole idea of a Hunter coming down to other planets to hunt dangerous game. The preserve planet idea is like.. taking toothed and declawed animals, and hunting them with military grade weaponry and completely defeating the purpose of a thrilling hunt which was what the first two movies were about. Also I felt that the Super Predators devalued the original concept of the creature.
Quote from: Russ on Jan 03, 2015, 08:46:30 AM
If tmjhur is right (or even partly right) Shane's movie may function in a wider universe that we don't even know is being built. The shared universe stuff is hot right now -- Disney and WB are doing it with Marvel and DC. Then again, Fox does have Star Wars! But that's pitching at a whole other audience.
Hollywood seems to be following a trend, and what works for Marvel and DC... may not entirely work for other franchises out there. You have to remember that Alien and Predator started off as two separate universes that had nothing to do with one another. Then the connections were made in comics-- something relatively obscure to the average joe blow movie go'er. The two movies were never part of the same universe until Predator 2 hinted it with the Xenomorph skull. Then people got talking. Then we got the AvP films... Whether or not you count them is up to an individual fan but the whole shared universe thing? Well.. what works for Marvel and DC, may not exactly work for Alien and Predator.
I mean the whole shared universe thing with Alien and Predator started off as a comic book. But right now, I am just preaching to the choir. But from how I am seeing it anyway, for Fox to take the approach of taking the old EU (as far as AvP's original shared universe concept is concerned) and tossing it out.. well, they're taking the original core and replacing it with a new core. In other words... You're replacing an old car engine, and replacing it with a different manufactured one. Does it run the same?
Also, Fox only distributed Star Wars when Lucasfilm owned the property. Disney now owns the IP one hundred percent.
Quote from: Russ on Jan 03, 2015, 08:46:30 AM
So maybe - just maybe - tmjhur is on the right lines and we could be getting a whole load of new stuff from Fox for us gnarly grown ups. Maybe someone there has realised that the older folks are the ones with the disposable incomes who will keep paying for stuff over and over again *lol*.
Oh there is no doubt that Fox is not going to be stopping putting out Alien and Predator stuff. Sure there are a few dry years here and there but then they put out merchandise and new stuff. Every franchise does this. But personally, I.. am not really feeling too much of the new stuff since PREDATORS and while I did like Prometheus, including Predator with that seems... I don't know a word for it but I felt Predator needs to be left out of that Prometheus stuff.
I have hope for Shane's movie.. I love a lot of his work as well as Fred Dekker, who is penning the script. I loved Night of the Creeps, Monster Squad was hella great, Ricochet was f**king great, and A Long Kiss Goodnight was interesting.. The only red flag about Dekker is the fact he wrote and directed Robocop 3.. and I love the Robocop franchise too but that movie killed his career and the Robocop franchise until it was resurrected with a reboot that came nineteen years later. Dekker even admitted it in an interview the folks over at Robocop Archive.
But I am cautiously optimistic.
I want this to be good.. I want this to be a movie I can like.. I truly do as my faith is in Shane, considering he did last minute rewrites with the first movie.