Quote from: SM on Oct 11, 2011, 10:10:43 PM
Quoteedit to add) also some of the cgi work and set work in the star wars prequels is not as obvious as you might think, i was quite dumbfounded when i watched all the makings and saw that some things i thought were real were cgi and some things i thought were cgi were actually sets.... example: obi wans cloak in parts of episode 2 were cgi....
Indeed. There's a shit load of stuff in Star Wars (and many other flicks) like sets that people would never pick as being digital.
agreed, to be honest, i dont think cgi was a problem on any of the sw prequels and i can understand why lucas used so much as sw is much more expansive than most sci fi/fantasy universes and would be very hard to do what he wanted without cgi, the problems were bad stories, bad continuity, bad casting, bad acting, bad scripts, bad designs and bad dialogue, the films did improve a little from 1 through to 3 but the damage was already done, ill still watch them though as im the type that will still watch any movie that contains my fave characters etc, ill probably be called for this but i can happily sit through avp and avpr just cos its got aliens and preds in lol
but anyway, ridley looks to have gone about prometheus the right way by doing it real wherever possible and just adding cgi where needed because i feel the realsim is needed more in a thriller/horror film than something like star wars.
thanks
rich