Poll: AvP vs AvPR

[DoomRulz]

AVP-R is a film I can watch over and over (more action, ect.) However, as far as film quality goes, the first alien vs predator is probably better.(better acting, special effects, ect.)
So it just depends on how you look at it.

Not really, because the first AvP is only marginally better at best. How I see it, is that both films have something the other lacked. AvP had better acting and a slightly better script. AvP:R actually had some colour to it and had the action.

[That Yellow Alien]

Better atmosphere too.

[DoomRulz]

Which did?

[SpreadEagleBeagle]

AVP I hope

[That Yellow Alien]

AVP

[Nobody]

I still think AvP UNRATED

f**king Kills AvP-R's horrible acting and non-stop gore that's even too dark to enjoy.

[DoomRulz]

I will always choose AvP:R's action and setting over AvP's boring and stale people running around in dark corridors.

[The Demon]

Exactly. Like when Scar does the slasher chase to Lex, Sebastian and Wayland. What was with that? Remember how creepy the original Predator was climbing around trees cloaked? And in this AvP we get a Predator that stalks his prey but walking after them.

[PREDATOR1125]

avpr was waaaay to dark. avp is better

[War Wager]

Uggg... I reckon I can only get one more viewing out of Requiem. And it'll probably be with the commentary turned on.

Trust me, you don't want to listen to that. It's awful.

[Flaming Firefox]

I watched AvPR the other day for probably the final time, that brings the  grand total of times I've seen it to 3. I really don't think I could sit through watching it again.

[DoomRulz]

Uggg... I reckon I can only get one more viewing out of Requiem. And it'll probably be with the commentary turned on.

Trust me, you don't want to listen to that. It's awful.

Director's commentary, yes. The ADI track isn't too bad though.

[War Wager]

Not at all. Especially listening to them mock the movie.

[The Demon]

I don't get how AvPr is winning. I thought the majority here preferred AvP?

[Undeadite]

Could be we have an overwhelming case of groupthink here on the forums...