Quote from: MadassAlex on Apr 15, 2010, 02:20:10 AM
The changes to the head are pretty significant.
Really? What is so significant about it when no additional parts were designed for the head and teh entire head is of gioger's design?
Quote from: SpaceMarines on Apr 15, 2010, 02:21:55 AM
Removing the dome is a significant change.
But not a redesign and what under it is still all Giger's design
Quote from: Sabres21768 on Apr 15, 2010, 02:38:18 AM
How can you NOT consider removing the dome and skull a redesign?
Its not. Its a change but not a redesign. There still isnt an original line that would be designed and sketched by Stan or James
QuoteThe dome was a HUGE part of what the creature was in the first film.
No one is saying it wasnt. But Im also a huge Giger fan for more than a decade now. I prefer to see his terrific designs rather than no deisgn at all (dome). Its not the issue anyway. The point is that whats under the dome is Giger's design, not Stan's and not James'
QuoteYes, you couldn't see the skull, but it was there.
I know, but it was never intended to be seen. That continues to the sequel
QuoteAnd removing it is a MAJOR design change no matter how you look at it.
I dont think you understand what desgn mean. Removing is not designing orginal part. You seem to imply theyre one and the same
QuoteAlso, I've seen you state that they didn't change anything under the dome and that it looks EXACTLY like Giger had it on his creation.
This is definately not true either.
How is it not true? SHOW ME A LINE OR A NEW DESIGN ADDED BY STAN OR JIM TO THE HEAD. SHow me. Shape and designes on the head ARE identical.
Look at this trick
Giger's design
And now warrior
But no, youre all right. the head was redone, redrawnm and changed by Winston and Cameron. It has nothing to do with Giger's design at all
QuoteI understand that you have your own website (and an opinion to go with it)...but you seem to NOT know exactly what you're talking about.
Thanks for being a douche to me and being uninformed yoursefl about both the designs and the site. Why bother, Youre all right. Warriors are completely redesigned, theres barely any of Giger design in it. Any single change from Alien is a sacrilege, no matter if good or bad. There, Im in your club now.