I liked AVP and AVP-R. The movie kinda went the wrong way when Lex ran away with Scar. At that point ... that wasn't a Predator to me anymore.
AVP-R? Tough one. The gore was there for ONE thing ... gore. Nothing more.
I have high hopes for this movie. Peter Jackson + Neil Blomkamp delivered District 9, which I really love. Rodriguez with Antal ... can't wait to see whats in store for us.