I did this a while back on a long road trip. Yes, I know I spent too much time.
Sorry for the lack of columns, I tried to edit it in the post box, but apparently I'm not very good at this. I copied from a spreadsheet.
Edge Magazine 80
Angry Joe 80
APGNation 90
PC Gamer 93
Eurogamer Italy 90
Telegraph 90
action trip 83
shack news 80
hooked gamers 75
ign 59
gamespot 60
gamefront 92
softpedia 90
games.cz 90
multiplayer.it 90
escapist 90
everyeye.it 90
ragequit.gr 87
spaziogames 85
strategy informer 85
level up 85
ausgamers 85
3djuegos 85
destructoid 85
action trip 83
Merlinin Takazi 80
pcgamesn 80
joystiq 80
ign italia 80
kill screen 78
gamestar 73
riot pixels 72
slant magazine 79
eurogamer german 70
meristation 70
gryonline.pl 65
capsule computer 90
bloody disgusting 90
the independent 80
Hardcore Gamer 80
Trusted Reviews 90
stuff.tv 80
Gamerant 60
Polygon 65
eurogamer 80
mmgm 75
total xbox 90
metro.co.uk 70
guardian 100
gameinformer 77.5
videogamer.com 90
mirror.uk 80
venturebeat 83
Canadian Onine Gamers 84
Digital Trends 60
Gaming Trend 85
Digital Spy 80
Thatgameguy.net 100
arcadesushi 85
comic booked 90
wegotthiscovered 60
lazygamer 80
EGM 80
sixthaxis 90
playmag 90
empire online 100
nzgamer 85
yahoo 70
psu 85
Gaming Age 80
gamestm 90
irish independent 85
Huffington Post 100
Bit-gamer 93
ibtimes 80
techtudo 80
gaming nexus 90
iowa state daily 100
gameranx 85
Albequrque Jounral 100
Crave 70
Pocket Lint 90
Game Revolution 90
Gaming Bolt 95
ZTGD 65
MSN 75
Digital Chumps 76
Flickering Myth 95
True Achievements 80
Xbox Hub 80
nowgamer 90
Common Sense Media 80
Gamestyle 90
Den of Geek 50
newgamenetwork 64
maxigeek 90
biogamergirl 91
cheatcodecentral 68
XB1 UK 95
starburstmagazine 90
calmdowntom 80
JoBlo 80
Games Radar 90
AvPGalaxy 90
Average Score: 82.53
Reviews without scores:
Positive Reviews Negative Reviews
Yahtzee(Escapist) AV Club
GMANetwork Ars Technica
BadassDigest
Forbes
Rock Paper Shotgun
Slashgear
verge
Herocomplex
gatheryourparty
playstation lifestyle
uproxx
popwatch
shcoktilyoudrop
GQ
bleeding cool
good gamers
BBC
Gamecritics.com
Kotaku
If you count the negatives as a 1 and the positives as a 10 it rates a 9.14. Meaningless I know, but interesting.