Bishop in Alien 3 - Human or Android?

[maledoro]

His ear is smashed up pretty badly and can be compared to the damaged Bishop seen earlier in Alien3.

An elephant can be compared to a feather, too.

[wmmvrrvrrmm]

Gillis or Woodruff's claim that Bishop 2 was hit by a lead pipe was too much of a red herring, they either had no clue what was going on or couldn't remember

[The Chibi Kiriyama]

Gillis or Woodruff's claim that Bishop 2 was hit by a lead pipe was too much of a red herring, they either had no clue what was going on or couldn't remember

What makes you say that?

[wmmvrrvrrmm]

Gillis or Woodruff's claim that Bishop 2 was hit by a lead pipe was too much of a red herring, they either had no clue what was going on or couldn't remember

What makes you say that?

well, it certainly wasn't a lead pipe, that's for sure.

It was something looks as if it has a wide curved implement on the end which I suppose was the thing that cut deep into the flesh area behind Bishop's ear making it seem like a flap sticking out slightly

[Eidotemit]

it was a fire extinguisher if I remember correctly.

Because, apparently, its impossible to think that two people, of the same family line, could look the same. This must mean Hudson is also an android, since he looks exactly like Jerry from P2, and that just can not be. 

That's an excellent point.

I do what I can 

[maledoro]

well, it certainly wasn't a lead pipe, that's for sure.

That's cheap. The focus of that scene's commentary wasn't about what he was hit with.

[BlkSoul]

in famly some d look sorta alike down the famly tree

[wmmvrrvrrmm]

well, it certainly wasn't a lead pipe, that's for sure.

That's cheap. The focus of that scene's commentary wasn't about what he was hit with.

well, one thing for sure, to identify what the character was hit with or even understand the fact it wasn't just a weapon as blunt as a pipe would changes my perspective on the injury, and maybe other people's too

[wolf66]

 Before Aaron hits Bishop he says "f**kin' android"

[BlkSoul]

But after there is blood on bishops hand!

[wolf66]

But after there is blood on bishops hand!

The red blood is not proof enough that he was human. He was probably a different model.

[BlkSoul]

Well its sufficent. Because why would the Soldiers with him help him up if he was a robot/cyborg?

[wolf66]

  If he is human then Paul Anderson didn't really take Lance Henriksen's appearence in Alien 3 into much consideration when putting him and his character into AVP. Anyway we all have different opinions/ideas/theories. Every single person will never agree the same on something, but I guess that's what makes debating on something fun

[wmmvrrvrrmm]

Before Aaron hits Bishop he says "f**kin' android"

what do you think inspired him to believe that Bishop 2 was an android?

[severen76]

Before Aaron hits Bishop he says "f**kin' android"

what do you think inspired him to believe that Bishop 2 was an android?

Because ripley says that hes a bishop model sent by the company.