Bishop in Alien 3 - Human or Android?

[maledoro]

I've heard people say that the original Bishop's obvious duplicity in smuggling the egg on board the Sulaco proves that Bishop II was an android.

I hope they could explain why?

[Hudson]

That comment belongs in the "dumb things people say about the franchise" thread.

[Crazy Rich]

I tried to make sense of it... then I just decided to stop.

[DoomRulz]

Question 3:

If Bishop II was an android, why didn't he use his superhuman strength and speed to stop Ripley from closing the safety gate between them or rip through the gate to get to her, preventing the destruction of the embryo?

Mal, you're thinking too much like a rational person. Try to think more like a rabid fanboy.

[maledoro]

Question 3:

If Bishop II was an android, why didn't he use his superhuman strength and speed to stop Ripley from closing the safety gate between them or rip through the gate to get to her, preventing the destruction of the embryo?

Mal, you're thinking too much like a rational person. Try to think more like a rabid fanboy.

I can't. I've actually seen the movies and I spend most of my waking time amongst my fellow human beings in venues beyond my homestead.

[Terx2]

I've heard people say that the original Bishop's obvious duplicity in smuggling the egg on board the Sulaco proves that Bishop II was an android.

I hope they could explain why?

And how for that matter.

[Local Trouble]

Because evil Bishop 1 proves that all Bishops are lying evil liars, especially the ones who claim to be human.

[maledoro]

Because evil Bishop 1 proves that all Bishops are lying evil liars, especially the ones who claim to be human.

I'd buy that for a dollar. No...no I wouldn't.

[OmegaZilla]

I'd buy that for a dollar. No...no I wouldn't.

Thank you for your cooperation. Goodnight!

[Gilfryd]

I can't believe people still think Bishop from Aliens had ulterior motives. That was Burke. I don't buy that egg smuggling crap people think happened in Alien 3 for a second.

[OmegaZilla]

I can't believe people still think Bishop from Aliens had ulterior motives. That was Burke. I don't buy that egg smuggling crap people think happened in Alien 3 for a second.

I entirely agree. That's just some poorly constructed reason to justify the egg being there.

[maledoro]

It follows the illogic in "We didn't see it happen, so it must have happened."

[Local Trouble]

"You can't prove it didn't happen!  Why do you have to be close-minded?!"

[Crazy Rich]

It was the easter bunny with the lazy eye!

[Master]

f**k`in Voodoo Magic Man!