It won't feel the same for sure, but maybe around that level of comfort. If the joystick placement is what bothers some, well then I guess there's no way around that. Specially if they are switching companies. They are too used to one way.
I've had both, and while I do prefer the Xbox joystick placement, the PS one has never stirred me wrong. I know some people are going to be frustrated about that placement(if they're switching companies), but it's not THAT bad. You get used to it.