The Witcher 3: Wild Hunt, Finished the main story campaign, on one hand everything to do with the found family of Witchers and outcasts had me deeply emotionally invested in the outcome and I have never played an open world I can confidently call good before with an absurd wealth of superb side quests.
On the other hand as a sequel to Witcher 2 it is absolutely woeful, many of the major and minor political players from it are reduced to irrelevance if included at all, and in the end it boils down to a very binary good and evil decision in terms of what Geralt can do facilitated by both Radovid and Dijkstra becoming cartoonishly idiotic and repugnant in equal measure.
Where's the Emperor's consort? John Natalis? Ada and Anaïs and Saskia and Iorveth most of all? It is a testament to how well written the rest of the story can be sometimes that I still love it overall.