Quote from: ChrisPachi on Feb 29, 2012, 12:13:18 AM
Quote from: AmazSpiderMan1 on Feb 28, 2012, 11:51:03 PMEverybody is putting too much thought into this, as if Ridley and co. are trying to "erase" the AVP movies. They couldn't give a shit.
I disagree. It wouldn't of been that hard to work around the AVP stuff or at least leave it to the side, but they didn't. Instead they have completely replaced a fundamental character in the AVP timeline.
As far as Prometheus is concerned, AVP never happened. They are now completely separate universes.
-Chris
What I'm saying is, I doubt they even care to know about the canon in the AVP movies. Do you think any of the creative talent in charge popped in AVP:R and took note that Ms. Yutani existed? I highly doubt it. Infact, Ridley Scott keeps saying this film stands on it's own, with "barely" any connection. You're over-thinking something that Scott has put no thought in himself. He's using Alien as a spring board for an entirely different film, not dwelling or worrying about canon. I'm wondering why he even bothered relating this film to Alien at all. I'm honestly guessing because he kind of promised Fox an Alien prequel, and the idea of creating an original sci-fi film came later.
Let's be honest with ourselves here: whether or not this fits into the Alien series as a whole is up to personal tastes of which films you enjoy. The studio is saying virtually nothing on the matter, so it's wishful thinking this either ignores other Alien films or acknowledges them. It's not like in Halloween H2O, where the film makers were being blunt and saying, "Yes, we are IGNORING Halloween 4-6." You are basing this all on a piece of marketting for the film, and that will mean very little if they don't make any direct continuity statements within the film itself. Statements I doubt they'll make because Ridley Scott doesn't care. He's just trying to make an interesting, thought provoking film. Whether it fits in with the series is inconsequential.