It's definately ALIEN 5 for me!!
While I agree with what most people are saying here, in that the Alien series has seemingly lost its way while the Predator series has still a lot left to tell, I'm not really a big Predator fan. For me, too many people are stiill so easilly put off by the failures of the last 2 Alien movies. I agree Alien 3 and A:R had their faults, but that doesn't mean its over, even those movies still had a lot of creativity in something we had never seen before, all that was really lacking was the story telling. As someone here already said, each one follows the next so, in my opinion, the next logical step would be having Aliens on Earth...just my personal opinion. Another thing people seem no say a lot with no real justification is "no more Ripley". Ok so Weaver is a little told old for the part but the Alien series IS about Ripley, as it has been since the first sequel, and her story has to end before someone else comes in or it just wouldn't look right. What we need here, again in my opinion, is an Alien 5 that answers the questions left behind in the movies, especially the last 2 for obvious reasons. How did the Alien Egg get on board the Sulaco, what happened to the Company, who or what is the Space Jockeys? Answering questions like these is actually the MAKING of Alien 5 for me, all we really need now is a great writer to tie those loose ends together. I know who my money would be on, same as many of you no doubt, but as we've seen with AvP, FOX has a terrible habit of letting the fans down...I guess all we can do is wait and see.