I think the nature of the game is such that those who like to be more in control and have straight up action will probably not take to the game very well. I think it's just one of those games that may get less positive/average reviews from those who are not into this type of pure survival horror where your character is constantly on the back foot every inch of the way trying to (barely) survive - not to mention lots of dying and re-trying particular stretches of the game.
I think if the game averages out on a nice fat 80/100 (or 8/10 whichever you prefer) they can give themselves a pretty hearty thumbs up. If it averages anything close to or around 85/100...i'd say job very well accomplished.