This is a story I'm working on, but I'm just pulling a Halloween and just doing a direct sequel to the original and Dutch will be back. I'm ignoring Predators and The Predator. I'm not exactly ignoring Predator 2. I still like that film and it's definitely a nostalgic trip if anything and there are elements to it I still like that I would feature in my story, but ultimately, the suspense and mystery surrounding the Predator that you got from the first experience watching Predator is obviously gone because of how exposed the creature has been too variable degree in each outing. So that's why I think its best to bring back Dutch and make him the centerpiece much like Alien did with Ripley. Because if you create a new story with new characters and their encounter with a Predator, in the present, future or a past in a period piece, its still ultimately going to be the same thing over and over again, and the audience will already know more than the characters when they're trying to figure out what the Predator is. And if you try to keep and adding new stuff to the Predator, it just demystifies the creature and makes him less scary.
So in my story. It's not perfect, but just some ideas I'm playing around with. taking place over 30 years later, and obviously taking notes from the new Halloween film, Dutch is basically suffering PTSD from his encounter and his team being killed by the first Predator. He's been written off since as being crazy for trying to tell his story that an alien killed his team. After that, he went on to write and publish several books about his missions that subtly references the Predator, but doesn't directly call it an alien, he just mentions it being an "invisible enemy" with superior technology and how it was defeated with the use of "mud". I bright back the mud aspect because its nothing that really been revisited. Predators did, but it wasn't till the end of the film. Even though mud doesn't really block heat, it's just a movie and you can say it blocks the thermal vision from the Predator has because why would it be the same as humans?!
So I just think, what if a group of characters have that from the start to really turn the tables on the Predator? So in addition to writing books, Dutch has also set up his own international security company and is self-funded and has been prepared if another Predator returns, having developed new mud-based camouflage with military gear and equipment. I don't think it sounds to far-fetch because if you look at a ghillie suit, it uses plants/grass vegetation and as camouflage, so just imagine a uniform and guns basically coated in mud.
So anyway, Dutch usually only take clients around the world who are former criminals or been indicted or waiting to be convicted, war criminals. and want protection. He does this in hopes of drawing out a Predator because he thinks they would all worthy prey.
Dutch is contacted by a client to hire him and his company for protection (I was thinking maybe 1 or 2 other characters working with Dutch). The client is a former Special Forces operator and convicted war criminal who operated during the Yugoslav wars in the 1990s. And he is also an heir to a wealthy horse dynasty, so his family has a lot of wealth and influence. It turns out he read Dutch's book and the real reason he hired Dutch was that he had an encounter with the Predator in Bosnia that killed 2 of his teammates and severely wounded him with the plasma cannon, burning half of his face when he tried to avoid it, and only survived when he hid under some dead bodies and dirt and mud and blood, and since then has a God Superiority Complex to him and thinks he's a God and was able to best the "devil" and wants to go after a Predator himself with Dutch's help. And Dutch obviously sees this as an opportunity as well to get his story out.
Still working out how to go from there, but now you have a group of characters who know what the Predator is, so it's easier to kinda build back up that suspense with not showing the Predator (because that's how I'm writing it) because you're not following a group of characters trying to figure out what is killing them again, but rather how to survive. Plus, they'd be using the mud camouflage the entire time as well (just think Navy SEALs, but covered in mud), so it'd be really flipping the series on its head, and trying to outsmart and stalking the Predator. And with Dutch back, you still got someone to be invested in much like the Alien series did with Ripley. And that was kinda a problem I had with Predator 2. Dutch was able to outsmart the first Predator, obviously unintentionally with the mud, and somewhat turn the tables but there's still dread to it because if he makes to much of a sudden movement, the Predator would be able to see. The Predator is under no illusion that he can't beat him just because he can't see him. It's just another challenge for him. But in Predator 2, at least up till the slaughterhouse sequence when Harrigan blasts him with the shotgun, just seeing the Predator run away and Harrigan chasing it the entire time, you really lose that sense of dread. And its not so much that Harrigan outsmarted him the entire time, but rather through the Predator kinda being really clumsy honestly.
So that's where I'm going with my story.