Last TV Show You Watched

[Cvalda]

You should hear Shadow's hypothesis on Al, lol.

[ShadowPred]

You should hear Shadow's hypothesis on Al, lol.

It's the only thing that makes sense that completely deviates from the f**king obvious answer that everyone had in their head the moment Tui was being questioned.

[Vickers]

You should hear Shadow's hypothesis on Al, lol.

It's the only thing that makes sense that completely deviates from the f**king obvious answer that everyone had in their head the moment Tui was being questioned.

Is it in a post somewhere? >:3

[ShadowPred]

You should hear Shadow's hypothesis on Al, lol.

It's the only thing that makes sense that completely deviates from the f**king obvious answer that everyone had in their head the moment Tui was being questioned.

Is it in a post somewhere? >:3

Nope.

[Cvalda]

LOL, then write one.

[Vickers]

You should hear Shadow's hypothesis on Al, lol.

It's the only thing that makes sense that completely deviates from the f**king obvious answer that everyone had in their head the moment Tui was being questioned.

Is it in a post somewhere? >:3

Nope.

So what is it then? Slook.

[ShadowPred]

Top of The Lake theory that contains spoilers.

Spoiler

I honestly believe that David Wenham's character is the one who got Tui pregnant. He's close friends with the family, as we already know, and I do believe that the close relationship he has with the family; he abused it on Tui. He pretty much disrobed Elizabeth Moss, so we know this guy's a creep, and possibly did worse than change her clothes. We already know that Tui is not somebody that would rat out anyone. In the first episode we see Peter Mullan ask Tui if she said anything, and she basically said no. Now of course some people would take that as a hint that maybe Mullan had something to do with the whole situation, and FB seems to think that he does, but we all know why he asked her if she said anything, and it has to do with that secret Meth Lab in his home.

Last episode, Campion tries to throw you a curveball by having one of Mullan's sons tell him that he's seen him in and out of Tui's room from time to time. I am not gonna buy any of that bullshit, because I think Campion knows that everyone was thinking that Mullan got Tui pregnant in the first episode. Now she's just trying to re-inforce those thoughts because she knows she needs to keep us surprised.

In summary: David Wenham took advantage of the close relationship he has with the family, and Tui got the worst of it.

[close]

[Cvalda]

My guess:

Spoiler

Johnno raped Tui. And Robin will have to confront him over it, her heart in tatters.

Or something.

[close]

[ShadowPred]

My guess:

Spoiler

Johnno raped Tui. And Robin will have to confront him over it, her heart in tatters.

Or something.

[close]

Spoiler

Ugh, so it's gonna be some typical shit with Robin having to cry for who knows how long as she yells at him for being a f**king asshole?


NOPE

[close]

[Cvalda]

She gets her face splattered with blood from the previews, so I think it's safe to say the confrontation that happens is gonna be a bit more dramatic than that.

[ShadowPred]

She gets her face splattered with blood from the previews, so I think it's safe to say the confrontation that happens is gonna be a bit more dramatic than that.

It can't be him though, it's too lame. He's not even that great of a character to begin with, and no matter which way Campion takes him, he's going to stay boring.

[Vickers]

My theories:

Spoiler

The more I think about it, the more I stick with my original theory that Al Parker did it. He abused his professional position and his close relationship with the family. Also notice how he's trying so hard to get close to the character most focused on solving this case?

OR

Cvalda is right and Jane goes the "Johnno did it" route and have the person she's so close to tear her apart with this revelation.

I personally hope it's the former but more than anything I hope that it's neither of the two and that the finale completely surprises me. >:3

[close]

[ShadowPred]

My theories:

Spoiler

The more I think about it, the more I stick with my original theory that Al Parker did it. He abused his professional position and his close relationship with the family. Also notice how he's trying so hard to get close to the character most focused on solving this case?

OR

Cvalda is right and Jane goes the "Johnno did it" route and have the person she's so close to tear her apart with this revelation.

I personally hope it's the former but more than anything I hope that it's neither of the two and that the finale completely surprises me. >:3

[close]

You can just say, "I agree with Shadow."


But I don't think Cvalda's theory is the way the show should go, we already have his character having something to hide from Robin, and it has to do more with what happened at Prom Night than with current events, otherwise the flashbacks would be completely pointless to have him be there.

[Cvalda]

There was one fan theory I read that I thought would have been a brilliantly bitter ending: it would be revealed that Tui was dead, and she wasn't actually murdered by anyone. Instead, the women at Paradise tried to give her an abortion and accidentally killed her.

That's definitely not how it's going to pan out now, but I liked the tragic, horrible quality of that idea.

[ShadowPred]

There was one fan theory I read that I thought would have been a brilliantly bitter ending: it would be revealed that Tui was dead, and she wasn't actually murdered by anyone. Instead, the women at Paradise tried to give her an abortion and accidentally killed her.

That's definitely not how it's going to pan out now, but I liked the tragic, horrible quality of that idea.

Would have been bitter as f**k, but it would definitely be great since it gives the women of paradise an actual reason to be there besides being an excuse to just cast Holly Hunter, and having them being yelled at by Peter Mullan.