I really thought that avp 1 was about 1000x better than requiem. The only problems it had were the humans got kill'd off too quick, so there wasn't much time to develop the characters. It could've also used a bit more gunplay. Other than that, and the somewhat weak plot, the setting was brilliant. It was confined and dark just like the first alien. Avp requiem on the other hand was way to overly gory and just plain f*cking stupid. When I saw the trailer, I figured there'd be more marine action. If they could just make an avp film (possibly and hopefully going back to the pyramid scheme) and throw in more armed men, and create an aliens-esque setting, we'd be good to go.