Quote from: Infected on Mar 01, 2017, 04:06:17 PM
I agree on that, the part that holded everything together as a mystery was ripped apart by the outcome of the so called space jockey aka the engineer, it was proof or just stupidity to not understand your own franchise and mystery, to me the jockey scene in Alien before Prometheus, was maybe even more important then the whole xenomorph stuff.
And then building on Fassbender because he was magnificent in Prometheus as David is imo another flaw and another stupid choice,
and therefor not understanding your own franchise and the mystery that holds it together.
If you go on what i just said you can expect a good movie but it will not deliver us fans of what we hope and want from the franchise,
most likely a lot of superficial action survival horror with non to little in depth of Shaw and the engineers.
Im not dissing the movie but lets not expect much of the things we waited 30 years for.
Yes, take this film for what it seems to be (which is a good action movie at this point relying on everything we learn by date) and if delivers more than you expect, you will get a bonus :-)
Nevertheless, I still hold on to the fanboy hope to encounter the SJ creatures/or mentions of their extinction in the later films, yet it - even speculatively - can only see the light if
Covenant makes a hefty box office, so may it be successful with whatever path they chose it to follow.
Quote from: Darth Vile on Mar 01, 2017, 04:33:17 PM
These things are not mutually exclusive. It's entirely possible that Scott can deliver a good, well crafted action/thriller that some fans may not like. He doesn't really owe the previous films, or fandom, anything. I assume he's just trying to make a film that can entertain general audiences. Alien Covenant will stand or fall on how good a film it is, rather than how well it adhears to fans expectations.
Fair point about catering to the general folks! Yet, I feel that unlike the ardent fans, general audiences will have less patience for the same story told numerous times over and over again (and I am afraid that is the kind of response I'm kept seeing on wider-themed boards and in news comments).
You can still entertain general viewers with sprinkling some new ideas into the story.