Quote from: beej199 on Mar 03, 2012, 03:28:45 PM
There have been rejected scores for films before and on Ridley Scotts films....Legend is a good example - Jerry Goldsmith and Tangerine Dream....
In fairness, the Goldsmith version wasn't rejected. It was used for the European release, while the Tangerine Dream one was used for the US version. Both different cuts can be found on the deluxe DVD.
Scott prefers the European one. Personally, I've always preferred the US edition. The Goldsmith soundtrack has a few nice pieces in it, but there's something... Off about it. It doesn't quite gel with the visuals as much. The Tangerine Dream music also comes across a
lot darker, which really helps to convey the tangible evil atmosphere at certain points.
Also, as great as Mia Sara's singing voice is (which Goldsmith was apparently impressed by), the scenes of her character doing so feel a bit too much like a tale for children (which is particularly at odds with all the obvious sexual intonation of Darkness' seduction of her character). Taking them away makes it feel more dreamy and ethereal.