Poll: AvP vs AvPR

[SiL]

Mind you "A failed attempt to make us question our love of violence in the news" sounds like little more than an excuse rather than a theme.

I think it was good intentions done horribly, horribly wrong more than anything. Deodato was absolutely adament that's what they were aiming for, but fully realises they could've done it better, and a lot of critics use that statement against the filmmakers for what they wound up doing.

[DoomRulz]

Ugh, that film was so f**king out there. I mean, that film was just WTF. Everything in that film by and large, was done purely for shock value. The director did already admit to that.

A failed attempt to make us question our love of violence in the news.

But it did it have to be so graphic and wild? Tool wrote a great song called Vicarious which describes exactly that, yet it was still tasteful.

[Rebel-Blood]

Avp:
- 1 alien taking out 2 preds thats bull
- poor execution
- pg-13 rating

Now lets get to AVP:R
- worse execution
- newbie directors, no experience, no vision
- poor sfx
- No Score, ripped from other Alien/Predator movies
- Sounds ripped
- Scenes ripped from other Alien/Predator movies
- nobody actors
- horrible acting
- horrible setting
- overuse of gore to the point where you see it every 5 seconds and it gets repetitive
- military brought into story only because a few people die
- tries to be scary, fails
- fails as action movie
- fails as sci/fi movie
- only a few scenes worth seeing

Even with that i still like AVPR more caus im a Pred fan

[Puks]

1 alien taking out 2 preds thats bull

Captain, I am detecting large quantities of predator fanboyism in this sector.

[SamHain]

1 alien taking out 2 preds thats bull

Captain, I am detecting large quantities of predator fanboyism in this sector.

Or just common sense...

[SpaceMarines]

No, common sense would dictate that an Alien is better than the average Predator in hand-to-hand combat.

[Puks]

Exactly. And let's not forget those preds were unbl00ded n00bs.

[The Demon]

1 alien taking out 2 preds thats bull

Captain, I am detecting large quantities of predator fanboyism in this sector.

I'm detecting Alien fanboyism.

[SpaceMarines]

Just looking at the movies, it makes sense, don't you think?

[The Demon]

What makes sense?

[SpaceMarines]

*looks around nervously, leans in*

Nothing. Nothing about these movies makes sense!

[SamHain]

Nothing. Nothing about these movies makes sense!

I knew it!!!!

But anyway you are talking about the ''Alien is better than the average Predator in hand-to-hand combat.'' right?

[OmegaZilla]

- 1 alien taking out 2 preds thats bull

If it was one AvPR Alien, its tail harpoon would have broke like a cookie when trying to impale Gill, and it would have gone screaming.

AvP Aliens are just so badass because Paul WS Anderson liked the original saga.

[huntin8-t0n]

Nothing. Nothing about these movies makes sense!

Haha, so true!

- 1 alien taking out 2 preds thats bull

Though an alien would kill an unblooded predator in hand to hand combat, and then another one, but I think it was a poor idea to do it so, it made it look like the two preds died in a row.

[SamHain]

If it was one AvPR Alien, its tail harpoon would have broke like a cookie when trying to impale Gill, and it would have gone screaming.

AvP Aliens are just so badass because Paul WS Anderson liked the original saga.

If it was one of original aliens their tail wouldn't have extended to 3 meters just to kill Gill.
AVP aliens are so baddass because Anderson is alien fanboy.