Poll: AvP vs AvPR

[severen76]

I voted for AVPR.

I don't think I need to say why.

Why don't you?

[DoomRulz]

Coz he preferred it over AvP mayhaps?

[Bio Mech Hunter]

AVP's story has a more epic feel to me than AVPR, and if Fox had let Paul anderson do the R rated version of his story it would be more blatently obvious why AVP is better than AVPR...

it's almost comical how a terrible story (AVPR) with R rated violence is what sways most fan's favor... in my opinion of course...

Yeah, I concur. IMHO, Paul's been given a really (unfair) bad rap for AVP.

avp-r because i found it had a better plot then avp and the predator actually could kill an alien on a 1 on 1 fight

Because the Aliens were small. Because the Aliens were weak. Because the Aliens were dimwitted. Because Wolf can't be bothered with severe acid burns. Because the Preds in AVP were young and fairly inexperienced. Because the Bros. Strause are Pred fanboys. lol

[PREDATOR KING]

I have to say Avp r  was an improvement on Avp.
Eventhought the acting in Avp was Better the action and fight scenes in AVP R.
AVP's Fights were sort of short and would end when the fight would get good.
AVP R dident hold back on the gore like AVP did.
The Bros. did a great job in filming AVP R
Overall AVP R has my Vote   

[Dark Passenger]

I voted for AVPR.

I don't think I need to say why.

Why don't you?

actions speak louder then words

[Sol]

Voted for Requiem. Regardless of the situations that lead to AVP being what it is, Requiem was just a better product/film, in the end.

Enjoyed both, for the record.

[SiL]

Requiem was just a better product/film, in the end.

As much as I can see people saying they liked Requiem better from a fan perspective, I'm having difficulty seeing how it was, in any way, a better movie.

[DoomRulz]

It had better action at the very least.

[predator elite]

in each film they lacked something but in the other film they have what the other needs

[DoomRulz]

in each film they lacked something but in the other film they have what the other needs

What he said.

[Sol]

Requiem was just a better product/film, in the end.

As much as I can see people saying they liked Requiem better from a fan perspective, I'm having difficulty seeing how it was, in any way, a better movie.

You don't have to see it. It's how I personally view them.

[SiL]

I know, I'm just finding it hard to see the justification.

[Sol]

I didn't give one.

[SiL]

I realise this. Hence the difficulty.

[Sol]

Don't let it perplex you. You have your views on which is film superior, and I have mine. Nothing to get all hot and bothered about.