Poll: AvP vs AvPR

[The Demon]

Yeah, I don't know. It just doesn't look convincing. I feel they could of done something alot more convicing.

[DoomRulz]

How can you say AVP's setting was shitty? That was the best part of it, the set design was, as Paul Anderson would say "literally fantastic."

Set design and actual idea are two separate things. IMO, yes the design was perfect, but the setting was shit b/c it's a dead end; not much that can be done with a pyramid vs. a small town.

[The Demon]

How can you say AVP's setting was shitty? That was the best part of it, the set design was, as Paul Anderson would say "literally fantastic."

but the setting was shit b/c it's a dead end; not much that can be done with a pyramid vs. a small town.

Exactly. The Aliens do great in the pyramid but the Predator didn't. But in the town its better for both. Aliens get their places they work best and the Predator has its hunting grounds.

[Sol]

I liked AvP's settings. The pyramid, and the snowy Whaling Station were sweet. Definitely one of the things AvP has going for it.

[Craig]

How can you say AVP's setting was shitty? That was the best part of it, the set design was, as Paul Anderson would say "literally fantastic."

Set design and actual idea are two separate things. IMO, yes the design was perfect, but the setting was shit b/c it's a dead end; not much that can be done with a pyramid vs. a small town.

Aliens do not belong in a kitchen.

[DoomRulz]

How can you say AVP's setting was shitty? That was the best part of it, the set design was, as Paul Anderson would say "literally fantastic."

Set design and actual idea are two separate things. IMO, yes the design was perfect, but the setting was shit b/c it's a dead end; not much that can be done with a pyramid vs. a small town.

Aliens do not belong in a kitchen.

Really? Guess you missed the kitchen in Alien.

[Pvt. Hicks]

A full grown Alien opens a damn door, basically saying "Peek-a-boo!" to Carrie(I think that was her name), in a very man-in-a-suit manner.

[Uncanny Antman]

Really? Guess you missed the kitchen in Alien.

Nice try, but the chestburster is only ever in the dining area, not the kitchenette.  Aliens do belong in a dining room. 

[DoomRulz]

Last time I checked a chestburster was an Alien.

[Craig]

A chestburster that's not in the kitchen. Thanks for proving nothing.

[Hell-Scorpion]

AVP:
Unfortunately this film was a piece of sh!t. And that's understandable once you see writer and director is Paul W.S. Anderson great F@cker-upper of such great game series as Resident Evil and Mortal Kombat. He even got the title wrong, It's Aliens vs. Preadtor not Alien vs. Predator, that was 2-3 videogames back in the early ninties. It's only good while you're watching it then you think when it's done and look back, "what the hell?!"
Problems:
1. the title
2. Predators dispalyed as honorless killers.
3. Aliens on Earth, what the hell?!
4. Problem 3 makes Ripely's death in Alien 3 even more pointless.
5. it was F@cking PG-13!
6. Shoulder cannons were too huge.
7. Predators didn't arrive with shoulder cannons.

AVP-R
An improvement to say the least. Shame Lance Henrickson was in AVP, and not AVP-R.
Problems:
1. still on earth
2. no queen
3. no real winner in this one
4. the Pred-Alien becoming part queen

I think AVP-R was much better...

[DoomRulz]

It's been said before and it shall be said again: both films had something the other lacked. AvP:R IMO was better than AvP, but that isn't saying much.

[SiL]

AvPR had all the problems of the original minus the teamup, compounded by a complete lack of internal logic, let alone logic with the other films, and a worse plot.

[Johnny Handsome]

AvPR had all the problems of the original minus the teamup

Not true at all.
It had blood this time arround, fixed predator, better aliens and didnt waste the first half of the movie.

compounded by a complete lack of internal logic

Whats so un-logic about a spaceship crashing on earth releasing aliens on a small town??

and a worse plot.

f**k the pyramid build by Predators for a f**king blooding ritual, i´ll take a clean up job and a small town anyday.

[marrerom]

It had blood this time arround, fixed predator, better aliens and didnt waste the first half of the movie.

LOL! right, and AVP had better predators.