I'm not sure what this means but it doesn't sound good at least from this guys perspective.
-I would re-skin L4D with xenos and marines.
Does that mean everything including animations created for ACM are totally trash to HIM? Thats too subjective.
-I would have put large player trigger scripted events in each map that would modify the flow of each level dramatically.
Something tells me that this game has a fairly consistent pace. Which isn't bad, but I guess he imagined more breathing room and a chance to do more interactive segments or something.
-i would have more game modes and focus less on the license and more on making a great FPS.
This probably means that there are far more shooting going on than there is an actual interactive game being played. hense the interactive segments could proabably have been pushed.
Thats just my perspective here. So far we havent seen any diary logs or interactive components of the game that breathe life into this story. I think there was a mention that we might meet Newts mother, but man, i would like to know how much more there is in this game.