Quote from: necrotard on Apr 03, 2018, 02:57:40 PM
The aliens are animals. They can't carry a plot. There's only so much you can do with them. Alien movies where the aliens are literally the only villains would simply be mindless slasher monster movies. This series has always aimed higher than that. These films have always needed other villains to propel the aliens along and keep the story more interesting than just watching a crew get picked off one by one. The Weyland Corporation has always been the real villains of this series. I don't understand why the greedy corporation angle has always been embraced, but a villainous android suddenly gets tons of backlash from fans.
A. Animals can carry a plot (Jaws, The Birds, The Lion King, Free Willy etc').
B. The aliens are more than just animals ("What do you mean
they cut the power? How can they cut the power, man. They're animals!").
C. Of course the aliens can carry a plot. They've been carrying at least 4 plots in films alone. Their ability to carry a plot is why this forum exists in the first place. Yeah, sure, Weyland Yutani are the antagonists in the films, but their schemes are B plots. They aren't the main event. They never were the main event. You make them the main event and you get...well, Aliens:Colonial Marines.
The greedy corporation angle has always been embraced because the films were always about exposing the hubris and folly behind it. The films had something to say about their greedy ideology in the face of an indifferent and hostile universe. Covenant has nothing to say about David. He's just a space hitler, and his entire plotline undermines the very core of the Alien universe. Mankind is not an insignificant species that should act with caution about the things it might encounter in the far reaches of space - It's the center of everything.
Quote
These creatures were created from a mixture of DNA from various alien lifeforms using a biological weapon developed by alien lifeforms, and it happened on a planet other than Earth. Just because a man-made robot was stirring the pot, these creatures still meet every definition of the word "alien".
Actually, a man-made robot stirring the pot is all you need in order to not make it an alien, especially in a series of films where colonizing other planets is a norm. In the context of the Alien universe, being made on Earth is irrelevant. The xenomorph is about as alien as a Hedley's Hope produced iPhone. It's about as alien as Newt, for that matter.