All Star Wars

[Immortan Jonesy]

Eh, I always thought the ANH saber fight was lame. More so after seeing RotS and then even more after seeing Rogue One. Probably going to get flak for this but that SC 38 Re-imagined video makes more sense than the actual movie fight.

Meh.  ANH showed us a couple of master swordsmen practicing an economy of movement in a duel to the death versus the overly choreographed ass-clownery on display in the prequels.  Also...

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Hh9GfZIGgjs

I'd say that Obi Wan has always been more powerful than Skywalker, even when he was Anakin.

Now about the duels...I'd like to see less choreographic Jedi fights and more like martial arts.

Seriously? LOTR and Alien/s/³ and First Class/Days of Future Past/Logan. All superior Trilogies.

You're quite right.

[Local Trouble]

I'd say that Obi Wan has always been more powerful than Skywalker, even when he was Anakin.

Anakin probably had more raw potential, but Obi-Wan had more training and experience.  That counts for a lot.

[Immortan Jonesy]

I'd say that Obi Wan has always been more powerful than Skywalker, even when he was Anakin.

Anakin probably had more raw potential, but Obi-Wan had more training and experience.  That counts for a lot.

Anakin is like the prequel trilogy: a lot of raw potential but inferior execution. Obi Wan, on the other hand, is like the personification of the Original Trilogy. 

[Highland]

Seriously? LOTR and Alien/s/³ and First Class/Days of Future Past/Logan. All superior Trilogies.

LOTR is obviously THE trilogy....but it's a book. Aliens is mad disjointed and clearly made up. X men isn't even linked (Wolverine aint even in First Class outside of the bar).

The OT is about a boy that wants to be a Jedi, then kisses his sister, then watches his sister actually fall in love with his mate ( and they blow up two super bases in the same timeline). Insert kinda random Emperor baddie ala sequel trilogy but not quite as bad.

The OT is quite literally the story of one boy turned to the darkside, planned out and realised. However shit it may be, editing, acting, bad dialog, the prequels are undeniably the most linked story's in the Skywalker saga, by so many miles.

OT was done off the cuff, sequels were done off the cuff. George had a beginning, middle and end in the prequels.

[Voodoo Magic]

Please, none of you have a clue what realistic saber fighting looks like.

This is realism to a T:

Spoiler

You're all lucky Voodoo is here to teach!

[close]

[JokersWarPig]

as much as I enjoy realism, it can stay tf out of my light saber fights 

[Voodoo Magic]

as much as I enjoy realism, it can stay tf out of my light saber fights 

Yeah, I have to agree mostly with this sentiment.. as long as it doesn't get too ridiculous.

[Immortan Jonesy]

Please, none of you have a clue what realistic saber fighting looks like.

This is realism to a T:

Spoiler

You're all lucky Voodoo is here to teach!

[close]

[Local Trouble]

as much as I enjoy realism, it can stay tf out of my light saber fights 

Yeah, I have to agree mostly with this sentiment.. as long as it doesn't get too ridiculous.

I think that ship already sailed.

[Immortan Jonesy]

as much as I enjoy realism, it can stay tf out of my light saber fights 

Yeah, I have to agree mostly with this sentiment.. as long as it doesn't get too ridiculous.

I think that ship already sailed.

As great as it looks, I always thought it looked like a lot of people dancing for a musical...at least in some parts.

[JokersWarPig]

Ah yes, the fight where the bad guys drop their weapons for literally no reason. Thanks Rian.

[Voodoo Magic]

Yeah,with that scene in regards to ridiculous saber fighting, the shark was officially jumped.

[DarthJoker45]

[JokersWarPig]

I can't wait to see the Bad Batch fully animated.

[Shasvre]

Concept art from Trevorrow's version.

https://www.comicbookmovie.com/sci-fi/star_wars/star-wars-duel-of-the-fates-leaked-concept-art-shows-kylo-rens-new-mask-darth-vaders-return-and-more-a172851