Quote from: windebieste on Mar 08, 2016, 11:18:17 PM
Quote from: pred169 on Mar 08, 2016, 10:08:28 PMcould the reason there was such a limited amount of people be that it was only a custodial group? Graveyard shift if you will. Just a thought I had.
Some fans will put forth the idea that the colony was solely set up to discover the derelict and it the population doesn't need to be more sustainable until the derelict was discovered. Which is fine - up to a point.
In which case, if the colony was planned to become infected by WY, why send in the marines? Wouldn't a research and observation plan be better suited to the long term goals rather than a search for survivors rescue mission? Maybe Ripley's arrival at Gateway threw a spanner in the works... Who knows? It's all speculation at this point; but all of a sudden all the justifications become more convoluted and complex. The background for the colony is set up for the critical elements of the narrative to take the course they did without too much close scrutiny for its existence.
Really, if it takes 17 days for the marines to expect a rescue, then any genuine Colonial ambition on part of WY would be shuttling bus loads of colonists to Acheron at least once a month. After a decade, the location should be a bustling community of thousands of people assisting in the terraforming of the planet. As it stands, the size of the colony only serves the story Cameron presents to us without any greater exploration of its purpose.
-Windebieste.
That's kind of what I was thinking was a shuttle system. But I'm looking at it from an operational standpoint. As we see in multiple plants in the world. You have certain times where there is a skeleton crew in place. Whether it be for a maintenance shutdown or just a cooldown cycle. Or perhaps it could even be environment related. Like certain areas or the world today that have to slow production due to a rainy season or winter season or sandstorms or whatever the case may be.
Obviously this is a stretch I'm just trying to make sense of there being only a limited number of colonists. I know its a moot plot point and wasn't intended to be examined in detail but I'd like to think there was a logical reason for the limited colonists. Skeleton crew is the most logical thing I could come up with. Plus...we pick apart every other detail in the movie... why not this. [emoji1]
And you asked the question "why send marines?" That's an easy one to answer. IF.. and its a big if.. if they sent them their to become infected, the company would have to prove there was no malice intended. And that they did everything in their power to help the colonist. If they sent marines that pretty much takes away any ideas of corporate sabotage.
The science division would already know the marines can't contain the outbreak but ICC wouldn't know that. So they get more specimens to study and the suspicion is lifted. And.... who's to say they didn't already have a science team en route secretly?
Now with that being said I don't feel the company built the processor and limited the amount of staff with the intent of infecting everyone. I subscribe to the idea that a sect within the company sent the coordinates of the derelict only after the flight recorder from the nostromo was found. I also feel that they had no idea of the gestation rate and were not planning on the survey crew returning to the facility. I feel like the intent was to have one maybe two specimens to capture and study. And that when the crew returned to the facility things got out of hand and the colonists just weren't prepared to handle this kind of situation. The one gestated alien emerged and started collecting colonists one at a time and took them to a makeshift hive where it had been moving the surviving eggs from the derelict. Including a queen. The colonists were then cocooned for implantation. Before they knew it there were teens of aliens, then twenties, then thirties, and so on until they whole colony was impregnated. I feel that once the first few emerged that's when coms went down and that would have given the aliens plenty of time to gestate before marine arrival.