Topic: In your opinion do you think Alien 3 killed the franchise?

• “Alien Is On Some Level The Complete Opposite Of Star Trek. It’s Sort Of About Humanity At Its Worst” – Noah Hawley Talks FX Alien Pitch
• Aliens: Last Stand – New Aliens Fan Film Starring Aliens Alumni!
• Alien/s Concept Artist Ron Cobb Passes Away Age 83

[HuDaFuK]

The "I died" bit always makes me smile too.

[Huggs]

Resurrection gets at least 1 star from me, just for Mike Wincott.

[SM]

The "I died" bit always makes me smile too.

Couple of my faves are:

"Does that compute?  Or do I have to draw you a schematic?"
"Hey, I'm not the mechanic, ironsides!  I mostly just hurt people."

Even the latter line was improved from Whedon's clunky "I mostly just hurt guys".

At the other end of the spectrum...

RIPLEY - Get away from me.

JOHNER - Why should I?

RIPLEY - Because pain hurts.

[Corporal Hicks]

The "I died" bit always makes me smile too.

That's probably my favorite bit of humor in the film. I think it works when it's being dry like that.

[HuDaFuK]

"Hey, I'm not the mechanic, ironsides!  I mostly just hurt people."

I'd forgotten about Johner calling Vriess Ironsides. Yeah, that one gets me too

[[cancerblack]]

The "I died" bit always makes me smile too.

It's a quality gag, and one of the few that fits well with previous entries in the series.


However, I still maintain that it's a good-but-not-great movie - without any caveats or conditions like so many apply to it. None of this "good sci-fi, bad Alien" stuff.

However, basically everything sucks compared to Alien and Aliens, so that's a dishonest metric. As an admittedly unnecessary and gimmicky continuation of the Ripley story, it manages to be both an exploration of the weirder aspects of the franchise and an absolutely gorgeous funhouse ride.

And I'll defend it to the bitter end as a decent, strange, nightmarish Alien flick.

[EJA]

As flawed as it is, I'd take A3 over Resurrection any day.

[SM]

The "I died" bit always makes me smile too.

It's a quality gag, and one of the few that fits well with previous entries in the series.


However, I still maintain that it's a good-but-not-great movie - without any caveats or conditions like so many apply to it. None of this "good sci-fi, bad Alien" stuff.

However, basically everything sucks compared to Alien and Aliens, so that's a dishonest metric. As an admittedly unnecessary and gimmicky continuation of the Ripley story, it manages to be both an exploration of the weirder aspects of the franchise and an absolutely gorgeous funhouse ride.

And I'll defend it to the bitter end as a decent, strange, nightmarish Alien flick.

All this.

[Kradan]

As flawed as it is, I'd take A3 over Resurrection any day.

[Huggs]

Resurrection is...tolerable. Like a trip to the bathroom, if you dare to look at the end product for what it is, you see it's just a poo circling the drain in a shameful display of indifference. An unrecognizable hodgepodge of everything that was once grand and good, now coated in dirtiness.

One can either accept its existence as part of life, or continue to mourn for what could've been.

[Stitch]

As flawed as it is, I'd take A3 over Resurrection any day.

Yep

[LastSonofKrypton]

Resurrection is...tolerable. Like a trip to the bathroom, if you dare to look at the end product for what it is, you see it's just a poo circling the drain in a shameful display of indifference. An unrecognizable hodgepodge of everything that was once grand and good, now coated in dirtiness.

One can either accept its existence as part of life, or continue to mourn for what could've been.

I've said it before, Rez is to Alien as Hot Shots is to Top Gun

[Huggs]

I used to be able to enjoy it as an alien film. But having just watched it for the first time in awhile, the faults are becoming a bit more obvious now. The humor is good, but that's where the quality stopped for me.

Mike Wincott is still the man though.

[HuDaFuK]

I've said it before, Rez is to Alien as Hot Shots is to Top Gun

Hardly.

One is a black comedy with a lot of serious dark and f*cked up stuff in it, the other is outright slapstick.

[Huggs]

Part 2 was pretty good.