Alien Resurrection vs. Alien Covenant

Started by LastSurvivor92, Mar 28, 2019, 04:11:12 PM

A:R v A:C

Alien Resurrection
Alien Covenant
Author
Alien Resurrection vs. Alien Covenant (Read 7,651 times)

Voodoo Magic

The one thing I can say about Resurrection and Covenant is they really stand out!


Master

Quote from: Voodoo Magic on Apr 01, 2019, 09:15:18 PM
The one thing I can say about Resurrection and Covenant is they really stand out!

https://thumbs.gfycat.com/GloomyGreatBubblefish-size_restricted.gif


Huggs

Resurrections first half stinks.

Covenants last half stinks.

LastSonofKrypton

Quote from: Huggs on Apr 01, 2019, 09:36:59 PM
Resurrections first half stinks.

Covenants last half stinks.


Huggs

Had covenant continued with the slow moving horror of the first half, it would've been a victory for Scott.

Once David cuts his hair, it's all downhill. Way too much time was wasted in Flintstone town and on David crying. And the ending was just crap.

LastSonofKrypton

Quote from: Huggs on Apr 01, 2019, 09:43:57 PM
Had covenant continued with the slow moving horror of the first half, it would've been a victory for Scott.

Once David cuts his hair, it's all downhill. Way too much time was wasted in Flintstone town and on David crying. And the ending was just crap.

Would you have left the xenomorphs out of the movie?  Personally I would have, then again I wanted the movie to follow on Shaw's story, and see an actual interaction with the Engineers beyond just nuking them from the sky and killing Shaw off screen.

Huggs

Huggs

#36
I'd have changed the interior look of the ship to start. It's so boring when the last act begins.

Skipping ahead to the juggernaut, I'd have them spot the city from the crash.

After the neomorphs emerge and start killing them like in the movie, I'd have a running battle through the dark to the city, like in the book.

I'd have them spend a short time observing engineer technology and architecture, just to finally give us something to see, including David's lab. Asking questions and staring in horror at a dead civilisation. Then I'd have them find David and shaws remains, Shaw having killed him in self defense with an axe, and then herself dying of starvation or the pathogen. Meanwhile, Oram snoops around and gets himself facehugged.

Then I'd Give them about 5 or 10 minutes to evacuate at night and in the storm with neomorphs in pursuit. Oram survives but is too confused and weak to understand what happened, or is hiding his condition and hoping he'll be fine. He bursts onboard the covenant. A biomechanical xenomorph. David had perfected his creation. The last 30+ minutes of the movie is slow death and horror in the dark, similar to the original. Lope would also still be alive, and acting like a security officer, not some cry baby leaving his men to die like in covenant.

The movie ends with everyone dead, and the alien hiding and going into hibernation. As the covenant sails on to origae 6,  where the colonists will wake into hell.

Mid credits - a moan is heard in the dark, as we see daniels or others dying from egg morphing, the eggs to be used against the colonists.

[cancerblack]

Quote from: Huggs on Apr 01, 2019, 09:03:52 PM
Quote from: LastSonofKrypton on Apr 01, 2019, 08:50:10 PM
Both are awful, comparing the two is like trying to pick your favorite STD, or Limp Bizkit album

This is where someone says, "Core".  :laugh:

I was gunna say Three Dollar Bill Y'all


Quote from: Olde on Apr 01, 2019, 11:35:32 AM
Quote from: [CANCERBLACK] on Mar 31, 2019, 07:33:27 PM
You know i've talked to a few people who genuinely believe the fingering joke wasn't... well a joke, and was supposed to be a totally innocent line that became unintentional humour.
Fingering is the actual musical term, at least in English, for writing out or playing specific fingers or positions on a given instrument, and has been used in that context since at least the turn of the twentieth century, probably longer. See the image below. I guess I shouldn't have been surprised to see everyone misinterpret that word in the movie. It's an unfortunate association but ask yourself what other word would work in the context? "I'll do the playing"? But surely he isn't the one blowing into the instrument to make the music. In that scene, Walter does the blowing, David does the fingering. It's not the fault of the screenwriter if everyone nowadays is so addicted to porn that they read their own perversions into that dialogue.





My man, it was clearly intended to be read both ways, given the character.

Frosty Venom

Hands down Alien Resurrection, in my opinion.

Wweyland

Alien: Resurrection has a big nostalgia factor. Alien: Covenant has...a good novelization I guess.

Kradan

Kradan

#40
Quote from: Wweyland on Apr 02, 2019, 06:39:09 PM
Alien: Resurrection has a big nostalgia factor. Alien: Covenant has...a good novelization I guess.

Well, so all we have to do is wait another 20 or so years to like Covenant because of its nostalgia factor?

And novelisation was great indeed. And audio version was first audiobook in English i've ever listened. Oh, good memories.

Samhain13

Samhain13

#41
Alien Ressurection novelization was also an improvement over the movie.

Better explanation on the cloning stuff, more character development and their motivations, Aliens are described as looking like the original alien, parts from the Aliens' point of view, some alternative scenes are better on the novel, Newborn's description seems better(I imagined him looking baddass dammit :P) and he is a creppy bastard instead of a broken sad looking creature. The Newborn is more of a final villain, trying to kill Ripley 8 and laughs as he kills people. There is no sympathy towards the monster.

Oh I just realized this 2 movies have something in common: both have a novelization that fix issues on it.

Huggs

For the life of me, I can't remember squat about the resurrection novelization.

But I remember the covenant novelization was a big improvement over the film.

Mr.Skinsuit

One has an android in love with the alien the others android wants to destroy the aliens. Covenants synthetic man creates alien lifeforms and Resurrection man creates synthetic(clone) aliens.
::)

Samhain13

Quote from: Huggs on Apr 02, 2019, 09:34:18 PM
But I remember the covenant novelization was a big improvement over the film.

Preach!


AvPGalaxy: About | Contact | Cookie Policy | Manage Cookie Settings | Privacy Policy | Legal Info
Facebook Twitter Instagram YouTube Patreon RSS Feed
Contact: General Queries | Submit News