which is more offensive?

[Huggs]

They're not even remotely comparable, see my signature. 

What if the predators were harvesting big dick serum?

[Necronomicon II]

Well that'd be fine just fine. 

[The Kurgan]

They're not even remotely comparable, see my signature. 

What if the predators were harvesting big dick serum?

Then Dutch's team would be lucky that Jungle Hunter was only after their heads instead of their " serum".

[Necronomicon II]

So long as there's an endless corporeal nightmare of sinew, sex organs and mechanics that violently fuse flesh and technology in beautiful transfiguration via a sexually repressed, satanic A.I. playing with shoggoths - and no ancient space elephants - then we'll be fine just fine. 

[Xenomrph]

In the sense of actually being disrespectful to real-life people, then I'd say 'The Predator', but in terms of giving the middle-finger to the fans, the trophy goes to 'Covenant'.

[Voodoo Magic]

In the sense of actually being disrespectful to real-life people, then I'd say 'The Predator', but in terms of giving the middle-finger to the fans, the trophy goes to 'Covenant'.

Seconded

[Stitch]

In the sense of actually being disrespectful to real-life people, then I'd say 'The Predator', but in terms of giving the middle-finger to the fans, the trophy goes to 'Covenant'.

Pretty much exactly what I was going to say

[Oasis Nadrama]

Still of the opinion that Alien Covenant is an undeliberate but very strong celebration of rape culture. So that's the most offensive thing to me.

I haven't seen The Predator (will likely never do so, I'm through with watching pure shit) but the ableism/neuronormativity surely cannot compete?

[SiL]

How is it a celebration of rape culture when the rapist is explicitly the bad guy?

[Local Trouble]

Still of the opinion that Alien Covenant is an undeliberate but very strong celebration of rape culture.

Totally.  5 o'clock.

[SM]

Is Alien twice the celebration with two bad guys doing the 'raping'?

[Huggs]

Still of the opinion that Alien Covenant is an undeliberate but very strong celebration of rape culture.

Totally.  5 o'clock.

I've got 10:25.

[SiL]

Pretty sure the whole franchise is pretty ... pretty specific on the "rape is bad" thing. It's literally about rape monsters raping people and then they die horribly. Covenant is about a literally dickless incel inventing said rape monster specifically to rape and murder people.

At what point do we get to the "...and that's a good thing!"?

[Huggs]

Pretty sure the whole franchise is pretty ... pretty specific on the "rape is bad" thing. It's literally about rape monsters raping people and then they die horribly. Covenant is about a literally dickless incel inventing said rape monster specifically to rape and murder people.

At what point do we get to the "...and that's a good thing!"?

Apparently at 5 o'clock.

[Oasis Nadrama]

Already developed my thoughts in another post, to sum it up:

The fact David is the bad guy doesn't escape me either. (I was surprised you didn't bring it up if you were to dismiss the "rape culture" political criticism.)

Alien is about rape, okay. David is the bad guy, okay. Really, all of this is taken into account and all of this is okay.

The trouble comes from the fact David is incredibly enhanced and iconized. David is the true star of the movie.

(...)

The movie doesn't say David is right, but it romanticizes and idealizes him, while clearly establishing him as a symbolic, thematic and literal rapist (how do you call someone who literally organizes the unwilling penetration and fecundation of other individuals?).

The rapist depicted as beautiful, cunning and fascinating; as well as the deepest character in the movie: this is rape culture.

Director's cut here.