If you want to compare the scripts, but as a movie Alien 3 works (even if you want to call it 'flawed').
I am not a fan of the Eric Red script, however, or any of the alt Alien 3 scripts. Not having Ripley is a big mistake, would have failed hard. There are exceptions to that rule, but you don't get rid of your star if they're still in their prime.
When that happened, you have Predator 2, which is a good movie, but failed financially.