My only issue with Shaw was her accent of no fixed origin.
I noticed that too. I think she was trying to sound/imitate Scottish or English accent but failed miserably.
I agree: she tried to do English accent and failed.
It's impossible for Noomi to fail at doing an English accent. She's not trying to be English. She is speaking English in a way that is common for a person with her background.
Noomi is Swedish (living in Sweden and Iceland). I've been to Sweden and several people there spoke English to me with an English accept.
My Swedish girlfriend at the time told me that this accent was common with English language speakers in Sweden.
* I realize that the personal taste of many viewers results in a dislike of different kinds of accents.
- But the way i approach film often has this basis; if something exists in our world, then it can be put in a movie.