To be frank I think Neill Blomkamp is at about the tier of talent who could genuinely make a half-decent AVP film.
I am not a fan of Blomkamp's post-D9 work, to say the very least. And I hate the AVP films, and would be fine if that sub-franchise stayed dead. But I also like a challenge, and if you want to make a decent version of it he's one of the guys who is low enough on the totem pole now and might be good at it without it being unlikely because he'd be slumming. (See also: Neil Marshall who's very talented but very pulp, maybe Alan Taylor who's had his stock fall considerably since his GOT days, etc.).
But give Blomkamp Alien 5? No way.
I'll tell you who I would like to do 5: Fincher. And before we say it's impossible, the impossible happened the other day when the guy signed up for the sequel to World War Z. I never thought he could be f**ked to do that.