Finally watched it last night.
My expectations weren't high - I just wanted to be entertained for 2 hours . I enjoyed it pretty much. I liked that movie took more serious, more darker aproach than 3 and Genysis .
Spoiler
It seems to me many were very unpleased with the beginning of the movie but I really like that it started with death of Connor (and I have no problem with CGI in that scene ).Then again I like the beginning of Alien 3. I really dig the idea of Carl and like they make a new spin on idea of " friendly Terminator with Arnie face " . I like the idea that Sarah was forced to be allie with murderer of her son . I was quite surprised they weren't throwing Arnold at me from the beginning. It didn't feel like " Look, it's Arnie ! It's really him ! Look, look, he's gonna say his quote ! " And I think he even never said his " I'll be back " (OK, Sarah did but I don't care)
Future war flashbacks were ok. The main villain too .
Oh, and openning with imagery of Sarah in asylum from T2 was cool too
Ending was a bit too sugar-filled and reminded me of that cut ending from T2 with old Sarah
6,5-7 / 10 for me . And they really should stop there .